A Plea For Strep Throat Simplicity

A recent article published in the BMJ delightfully demonstrates that regardless of how we choose to overcomplicate the treatment of acute pharyngitis, our patients will all do just fine. The authors do have to be commended for their ambition as they attempt to supplant the mighty Centor’s claim as the clinical tool to guide antibiotic use. Not as self-aggrandizing as Centor, they named their rule FeverPAIN, an acronym for its five components. Their ambition is even more noteworthy as they endeavored to describe this rule’s derivation, validation, revision, bootstrap validation and clinical implementation all in one paper.
Despite the authors’ attempts to woo us with promises of bootstrapping and stepwise logistic regression, this study was essentially a pragmatic trial examining the effectiveness of three treatment strategies to guide antibiotic utilization in patients with acute pharyngitis. Patients (3 years or older) were randomized into one of three groups, either delayed antibiotics,  antibiotics as determined by the FeverPAIN score, or antibiotics as determined FeverPAIN score and a positive rapid antigen test.
Overall all three groups did well. The average duration of symptoms was 4 days. Both the clinical score group and clinical score + antigen test group had on average one day fewer symptoms than the delayed antibiotic group, all while receiving 10% fewer courses of antibiotics. Initially this finding seems counterintuitive. If more antibiotics were given in the delayed antibiotic group, how then did their symptoms last longer than those in the clinical score groups? Unless of course antibiotics played no role in this difference.
Its important to keep in mind that although this was a randomized trial, it was not blinded. Patients in both the clinical score group and the clinical score + antigen group had an experience in which the doctors spent time medically evaluating them and in some cases even running a “test”. Whereas in the delayed antibiotic group the patients had a less fulfilling experience, instructed to go home and a prescription for antibiotics would be waiting for them if they did not improve. Seemingly the prior two groups had a far stronger meaningful response than those in the delayed antibiotic group, demonstrating it is not antibiotics but rather talking to your patients and explaining the expected course of the disease that makes a difference on symptom burden. Interestingly the rapid antigen test added very little to reduction in antibiotic use and had no effect of length of symptoms.
This trial suffers from what is known as the Pollyanna Effect. If everyone will do well regardless of the intervention they receive, then it is almost impossible to show a clinically relevant superiority of one treatment strategy over another. More importantly with the incidence of rheumatic fever being so low it is considered clinically irrelevant. The question is not which of these strategies is most effective for the treatment of acute pharyngitis but rather is any treatment necessary at all? 
“Clinical score and rapid antigen detection test to guide antibiotic use for sore throats: randomized controlled trial of PRISM (primary care streptococcal management)”. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24114306

Nihilsm, Emergency Medicine and the art of doing nothing at emnerd.com 

4 thoughts on “A Plea For Strep Throat Simplicity”

  1. What a great paper if only for its readability — not even the topic! Clearly defined (and findable) primary/secondary outcomes and how the information was collected.

    From Appendix 1, for anyone else who was wondering, FeverPAIN:

    Fever, Purulence, Attend rapidly (3 days or less), severely Inflamed
    tonsils, and No cough or coryza

  2. What a great paper if only for its readability — not even the topic! Clearly defined (and findable) primary/secondary outcomes and how the information was collected.

    From Appendix 1, for anyone else who was wondering, FeverPAIN:

    Fever, Purulence, Attend rapidly (3 days or less), severely Inflamed
    tonsils, and No cough or coryza

Comments are closed.